Measured Against Reality

Wednesday, November 01, 2006

Solipsism is Everything That's Wrong With Philosophy

There was an article called Top scientist asks: is life all just a dream? on Digg yesterday. I read that article, and I yelled, “This is what’s wrong with Digg! Solipsism is the stupidest thing ever!”

In case you’re unfamiliar with Solipsism, it’s basically the position that nothing exists outside of your own mind. It’s essentially the philosophical argument that any five-year-old can discover and espouse as elegantly as the best philosopher, and in my experience most children do figure it out for themselves at some point.

It makes me angry for one very specific reason: even if it’s true, nothing changes. Yes, for all we know nothing outside of our consciousness actually exists and it’s all just a construct of our minds. But in that case what changes? Not a thing. Besides, it’s a ridiculously wasteful hypothesis, very unparsimonious, and you’d think it would have been sliced to pieces by Occam’s Razor long ago.

Why is it wasteful? Because in order for it to work, there has to be something that creates our consciousness (in the case of the aforementioned article, a computer simulation). But then we have to explain how that got created. All that it does is add another, pointless layer of complexity to the universe, one that we can never see or test and which is unparsimonious, and as such should be thrown out.

Appealing to the apparent fine-tuning of constants for life is also pointless. Imagine that, beings that can think find themselves in an environment that’s conducive to beings that can think. Quite the surprise! There may very well be no other way the universe can turn out, but maybe not, and either way the fact that we find ourselves in such a universe is not a surprise, and NOT evidence for an intelligent designer of any form, computer or god. To get to that conclusion requires healthy doses of sloppy thinking.

Solipsism embodies everything that I loathe about philosophy: untestable, predictionless, unparsimonious, and absurd. No one who seriously considers it as a possibility should call themselves a scientist.

Labels: , ,

22 Comments:

  • I don't know anyone who actually espouses this particular philosophy. Solipsism really exists only to shut down debate and make everybody have a lot of no fun.

    By Blogger Mr. Fantastic!, at 1:02 PM, November 01, 2006  

  • I'm a solipicist. And you can't prove that I'm not, especially because I can't prove that you are.

    By Blogger tlow, at 4:43 AM, November 03, 2006  

  • I agree with you, when you say that it is problematic - or ridiculous - to view the universe as "nothing but a simulation on some computer".

    But I think that the main reason this is problematic is, that a distinction is made between the computer (hardware) and the simulation (software).

    There are actually many things in physics, which is easier to understand, if you view it as some kind of "calculation" processes. The wave/particle duality might be an example, I guess?

    Another example: It might be even theoretically impossible to simulate the universe on a computer FASTER than the universe itself. Not that a simulation of the universe uptil now has to be impossible - but it would necessarily take MORE than 14 billion years (the age of the universe).

    What I am saying is, that there are good arguments for viewing the universe itself as a kind of Quantum Computer - without making a dictinction between hardware and software...

    By Blogger mogmich, at 7:31 AM, December 03, 2006  

  • I think people tend to get very annoyed with solipsism without really understanding what it is.

    Solipsism is really just a challange to naive realism, a way of way of contesting or at the very least *highlighting* an assumption that we all hold - in this instance that there really is a reality entirely external to ourselves.

    Dont let it wind you up, philosophy (especially epistemology) is just about challenging and sorting out what we *actually* know from what we assume to know.
    Even if you are completely sold on the scientific branch of philosophy, epistemology is still something you should champion or at the very least leave open to consideration.

    btw your argument against solpsism as simply envoking another unnecessary layer of complexity could just as easily be used against something like big-bang theory.
    If you want to follow a line of reasoning which takes simplicity to the primary desirable attribute, then youd really have to throw out alot of current scientific theory - Which more often than not simply leads us to even more complex sequences of questions rather than giving us a set of absolute answers.

    By Blogger oly, at 3:55 AM, December 11, 2007  

  • I didn't know it but the external world and other minds cannot be known and might not exist. In the history of philosophy, solipsism has served as a skeptical hypothesis. 23jj

    By Anonymous viagra online, at 1:58 PM, April 15, 2011  

  • it is really interesting to know about this particularly philosophy, I've never seem one article like this one is really informative, thanks for sharing this.

    By Anonymous Viagra on line pharmacy, at 1:52 PM, May 23, 2011  

  • I’ve been looking for some time for any nice content material articles in relation to this particular point . Searching in Yahoo and google I lastly discovered this url. After reading this submit I'm delighted to say that I get an exquisite uncanny feeling I stumbled upon the very things I used to be looking for. I most actually will make sure to don’t neglect this weblog and have a look consistently.

    By Anonymous cellulite removal, at 5:53 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • I’ve been looking for some time for any nice content material articles in relation to this particular point . Searching in Yahoo and google I lastly discovered this url. After reading this submit I'm delighted to say that I get an exquisite uncanny feeling I stumbled upon the very things I used to be looking for. I most actually will make sure to don’t neglect this weblog and have a look consistently.

    By Anonymous head lice remedies, at 5:53 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • Hey, my group is simply establishing our first web site, looking out and working out what's needed. This blog caught out right away. I’m fired up about this, and adore the design of your site. Can you let me know what “theme” it's?

    By Anonymous constipation in baby, at 5:53 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • I've been looking good information about this topic for a while and I gotta say you post offers me some basic idea about my paper I am gonna write for my assignment. I would really like copy some of your phrases right here and I hope you don't mind. Thanks. I'll reference your work of course. Thank you.Preserve updating the nice posts. will come back.

    By Anonymous treat yeast infection, at 5:54 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • Thanks very a lot for this flawless publish;that is the phrases that retains me on track by way of out the day. I have been trying round on your website after I heard about them from a buddy and was thrilled once I was able to find it after looking for long time. Being a avid blogger, I’m glad to see others taking initivative and contributing to the community. Simply needed to remark to show my appreciation to your website as it is vitally challenging to do, and plenty of writers don't get credit score they deserve. I am certain I’ll visit again and can spread the phrase to my friends.

    By Anonymous genital warts in women, at 5:54 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • Very nice articles. I’ve found your web site by Aol and I’m truly pleased in regards to the info you have got inside your post. By the way in which your blogs design is kind of damaged with the Chrome internet browser. May be actually great should you’re can fix that. Anyway keep in the nice operate!

    By Anonymous acid reflux diet, at 5:54 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • As on the lookout for quite some time for locating a useful articles or weblog posts with regards to this distinctive challenge . Researching in Google I lastly discovered this weblog post. Studying this So i am happy to say that I’ve got an excellent impression I came across no matter I wanted. I most definitely will you'll want to bear in mind this weblog and look constantly.

    By Anonymous yeast infection cure, at 5:54 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • I havent any word to understand this post.....Actually i am impressed from this post....the person who create this put up it was an excellent human..thanks for shared this with us.

    By Anonymous stop snoring devices, at 5:55 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • I want to thank you for the efforts you have made in scripting this article. I hope the same best work from you sooner or later as well. In fact your creative writing talents has inspired me to begin my own BlogEngine blog now. Actually the running a blog is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a high quality example of it.

    By Anonymous get rid of cellulite, at 5:55 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • I have been looking out good information about this topic for some time and I gotta say you publish offers me some normal thought about my paper I'm gonna write for my assignment. I would really like copy a few of your words here and I hope you don't mind. Thanks. I'll reference your work of course. Thank you.Hold updating the good posts. will come back.

    By Anonymous head lice home remedy, at 5:55 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • After I originally commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now every time a remark is added I get four emails with the identical comment. Is there any manner you may take away me from that service? Thanks

    By Anonymous constipation home remedies, at 5:55 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • Hello administrator, I’ve slightly request. I had been simply googleing for some info on the subject you revealed and found this post. Some very nice materials you posted right here. Can I if doable talk about this submit on my new website I'm creating? This may be terrific. I'll examine again but once more afterwards to learn the way you replied. Many thanks

    By Anonymous genital warts remedy, at 5:55 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • Fairly great write-up. I just Digging your site and desired to say that I’ve really loved studying your blogpost. Any way I’ll be signing as much as your feed and I think you’ll publish as soon as extra within the close to future.

    By Anonymous low cholesterol diet, at 5:56 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • Hello Webmaster, commenters and everybody else !!! The blog was absolutely fantastic! Numerous nice info and inspiration, both of which all of us need!Hold ‘em coming… you all do such a terrific job at such Ideas… can’t let you know how much I, for one admire all you do!

    By Anonymous blemish balm, at 5:56 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • Great points…I would notice that as someone who actually doesn’t remark to blogs much (in reality, this may be my first post), I don’t assume the time period “lurker” is very flattering to a non-posting reader. It’s not your fault at all, however maybe the blogosphere may provide you with a greater, non-creepy title for the 90% of us that get pleasure from reading the posts.

    By Anonymous sinus infection remedies, at 5:56 PM, June 09, 2011  

  • I think this sis something crazy but I think that's not stupid everything depends on our interpretation, because I think that every mind is a world and I think we can create thousands of things in that world that we've created, actually sometimes I've thought that we're living two lives at the same time specially when we are sleeping.

    By Anonymous Generic Viagra, at 7:02 AM, September 14, 2011  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home