Measured Against Reality

Tuesday, September 12, 2006

Is Fast Food Fat Food?

Many people have seen Morgan Spurlock’s Documentary Super Size Me, and many were convinced by his experience that fast food is inherently bad for you. What these people don’t realize is that Spurlock’s real problem is that he simply overate. Other people ate McDonald’s for a month straight and were skinnier and healthier after than before. Two good examples are Scott Caswell or James Painter. Even at McDonald’s it’s possibly to eat right.

But that’s not the whole story. Case studies are interesting, but rarely revealing or reliable enough to qualify as real science. That’s why I dug into the peer-reviewed literature in medical journals to find out all I could about fast food. I’ve condensed that down into some quick conclusions.

Continue reading...There are many problems with fast food, including “enormous portion size, high energy density, palatability, excessive amounts of refined starch and added sugars, high fat content, and low levels of dietary fiber.” The most important of those, at least in terms of weight gain, are the portion size, and energy density. I’ll focus on energy density first.

Energy density is simply how many calories are in a given volume of food. This is important because humans evolved eating things that have relatively low energy density, and as such our bodies are best equipped to deal with those foods. For example, if you ate enough apples to feel full and enough Big Macs to feel full, the Big Macs will give you much, much more energy, probably around 1,000 Calories more, which is half the daily Caloric needs.

This in and of itself actually isn’t a problem, it only becomes one when this energy isn’t used. The study by Ebbeling and colleagues found that while everyone eats far more fast food than required to satiate their energy needs, overweight people are much less likely to work it off. Why this is so is undetermined, but it points to the conclusion that burning the excess energy is the main concern with fast food, and that overweight people (for whatever reason) don’t do that as well as people of normal weight.

And this makes sense. People gain weight because they take in more energy than they use. So people need to be more careful with fast food because it has more energy per unit volume than we’ve evolved to deal with. People who don’t compensate gain weight, those who do compensate won’t gain anything.

Portion size is another problem, but one that’s spread across our entire culture. Portion sizes have increased on everything from bagels to fast food to candy bars, and we haven’t adjusted. For example, a standard bagel supplies the entire daily requirement for grain for someone on a 1,600 Calorie diet (2,000 is the recommended norm). This is significant for fast food, which we already know is energy dense. Eating a large portion of something with a high density and not burning off the Calories is a recipe for weight gain.

“Value Pricing”, where larger sizes are less per unit, is probably an important culprit for this trend, but there are doubtlessly others. Some studies suggest that eliminating value pricing is the easiest step we can make toward losing weight. But even then, it’s ultimately up to the consumer to decide what goes in their mouth.

The other thing to take into consideration is whether fast food is an aberration from a healthy diet, or typical of the diet. A study by Newby and colleagues found that diet correlates well with BMI, with diets high in fruit, vegetables, and whole grains being the best, and diets consisting of meats and starches were among the worst. But again, this just confirms what we already know, eating natural, unprocessed foods in a balanced diet is the best way to be healthy.

Where does fast food fit into that scheme? The surgeon general says that it can be eating as part of a healthy diet, but many might be skeptical of that. However, the evidence suggests that he’s right: as long as the energy is worked off, eating fast food is not bad. There might be long-term health problems because typical fast food lacks some vitamins and minerals, but every fast food chain now offers salads, which should supply the needed nutrients. The only fair conclusion is that fast food is not actually all that bad when proper balances used.

As always, the key to being healthy is eating right and exercising. We can indulge in high-calorie, “bad” fast food, as long as we balance it out. It might not be the conclusion Morgan Spurlock or the people suing McDonald’s for “making them fat” want to hear, but it really is simply up to the consumer to manage their own health.




Sources:

  • Boon, Gloria, et al. “National Summit on Obesity.” American Medial Association. October 2004. 19 May 2006.

  • Bowman, Shanthy A, and Bryan T. Vinyard. “Fast Food Consumption of U.S. Adults: Impact on Energy and Nutrient Intakes and Overweight Status.” Journal of the American College of Nutrition 23.2 (2004): 163-168.

  • Ebbeling, Cara B, et al. “Compensation for Energy Intake From Fast Food Among Overweight and Lean Adolescents.” Journal of the American Medical Association 291.23 (2004): 2828-2833.

  • Freeland-Graves, Jeanne, and Susan Nitzke. “Total Diet Approach to Communicating Food and Nutrition Information.” Journal of the American Dietetic Association 102:100 (2002).

  • Harnack, Lisa, and Simone French PhD. “Fattening up on fast food.” Journal of the American Dietetic Association 103.10 (2003): 1296-1297.

  • Jacobs, David R. “Fast food and sedentary lifestyle: a combination that leads to obesity.” American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 83.2 (2006): 189-190.

  • Newby, PK, et al. “Dietary patterns and changes in body mass index and waist circumference in adults.” American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 77.6 (2003): 1417-1425.

  • Prentice, A. M, and S. A. Jebb. “Fast foods, energy density and obesity: a possible mechanistic link.” Obesity Reviews 4.4 (2003): 187.

  • Pruitt, Julie D, et al. “Nutrition as a contributor and treatment option for overweight and obesity.” American Heart Journal 151.3 (2006): 628-632.

  • Young, Lisa R, and Marion Nestle. “Expanding portion sizes in the US marketplace: Implications for nutrition counseling.” Journal of the American Dietetic Association 103.2 (2003): 231-234.

Labels: , , , ,

21 Comments:

  • Do you have Lexis-Nexis for research? What do you use to obtain primary sources for citation? Medline?

    Good article, and the science is fascinating but my question is how do you get people to change their behavior? Coercion?

    So what weight do you put on the argument, posited by some, that the chemical composition of fast food and its effects on the body are addictive in their activation of the dopamine system?

    (http://banzhaf.net/docs/newsci.html for a cursory analysis with bibliography)

    By Blogger Red Fish Blue Fish, at 6:50 AM, September 12, 2006  

  • From what I've read, all food is addictive, but the ones that are the worst are sugarry foods, althoughy fatty and salty probably are too.

    It's up to the people themselves to change their behavior. If they don't want to be overweight they have to take initiative, whether it's diet and exercise or gastric bypass. I realize that for some it's more difficult than others, but it's really a personal thing.

    The articles were obtained while I was at school, so I had a lot of access. However, I think many of them are in public journals.

    By Blogger Stupac2, at 7:03 AM, September 12, 2006  

  • But they all taste good.That makes it addictive.Why does not spinach make people addiction ?Because it tastes horrible.

    Thanks

    By Anonymous diyetler, at 3:44 AM, May 14, 2007  

  • Fast Food is crap. Might as well eat out of the toilet.

    By Blogger Spidey, at 4:39 PM, June 02, 2007  

  • The strongest harm of fast food is considered to be a high energy density. It is a little bit wrong. Fast food contains easily digestible carbohydrates that lead to high blood sugar level. The emission of insulin into the bloodstream increases the appetite and slows down the metabolism. That's why if you would like to reduce, you should avoid flour and dessert meals.

    By Anonymous CreditNurse, at 9:04 PM, July 19, 2007  

  • I don't like diet :(

    By Anonymous diyet programları, at 2:54 PM, September 26, 2007  

  • I can hardly imagine fast food as a part of diet. Perhaps, only salads, then I agree but all other "dishes" are too far from the healthiest I believe

    By Anonymous Elisa, at 3:45 AM, January 29, 2008  

  • It is important to develop attention to the food, even when we are in a race to have time to eat a good meal. There are many different foods that are rarely considered only meals, but instead of completing a daily intake of snacks. It seems to me quite often feel adequately nourished after eating a few walnuts and keep the dinner hour. That is because nuts and cashews in energy products in particular. So when we come to drink, it is often thought that a quick solution with a soda from time to time will not hurt. If true, this is also true that a good cup of tea with milk and brown sugar actually fill the same need for a hot drink and will not put as many pollutants as a soft drink.

    By Anonymous fast food packaging, at 1:53 AM, February 10, 2011  

  • Nice post, I would like to request you to one more post about that Keep it up

    By Anonymous Careprost, at 12:38 AM, March 01, 2011  

  • Hey, Really great work,I would like to join your blog anyway so please continue sharing with us,

    By Anonymous Kamagra Oral Jelly, at 5:34 AM, April 14, 2011  

  • Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up!

    By Anonymous careprost, at 4:43 AM, May 18, 2011  

  • Well if you est fast food and you dont do exercise of course it is going to make you fat, you can eat it , but you have to do exercises.

    By Anonymous Buy Generic Viagra, at 7:04 AM, June 07, 2011  

  • Això és realment interessant, ets un blogger molt hàbil. M'he unit a la seva alimentació i esperem que busquen més del seu missatge meravellós. A més, he compartit el seu lloc en els meus xarxes socials !

    By Anonymous Generic Minipress xl gits, at 4:47 AM, June 09, 2011  

  • I've been searching for this topic for years. I'm glad of having finding it. It's a fantastic issue, and a beautiful photograph. Thanks for everything you have taught me!

    By Anonymous Networking solutions, at 6:27 AM, July 16, 2011  

  • I have wanted to learn more about particular topics, but not many websites would help me out in informing me the way I expected. This left me with many question, but after reading your article, I got an answer to all my questions. You are too cool dude!!!

    By Anonymous Generic Drugs Exporter, at 5:59 AM, August 09, 2011  

  • Find breaking news & Health news on medicine, fitness, nutrition, health care, mental health, drugs, Diet , pregnancy Weight Loss

    By Anonymous About Health, at 5:05 AM, September 27, 2011  

  • Great loved it, will be waiting for your future posts Thank you for sharing

    By Anonymous Avodart, at 6:17 AM, September 30, 2011  

  • Oh my god, there's a lot of worthwhile info here!

    By Anonymous www.muebles-en-lugo.com, at 1:37 AM, October 11, 2011  

  • I have no words to express how useful your blog was to me in completing my job work successful. Thanks a lot.

    By Anonymous Facebook Applications, at 5:27 AM, October 25, 2011  

  • Great information you got here. I've been reading about this topic for one week now for my papers in school and thank God I found it here in your blog. I had a great time reading this.

    By Anonymous Kamagra, at 5:01 AM, November 07, 2011  

  • Great Information you got here..thank you for sharing this knowledge with us.

    By Anonymous Sgfx Financial Limited, at 10:58 PM, March 10, 2012  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home