Measured Against Reality

Wednesday, May 30, 2007

The "Me" generation? I don't buy it.

The self-esteem generation (18- to 25-year-olds) is now moving into the workforce, and they're driving Boomer managers nuts. Kids who were used to being told how "special" they are at every turn by parents and teachers and getting gold stars for their finger paintings are apparently having trouble adapting to the real world in which managers merely expect them to do their jobs. According to National Public Radio:

Companies are hiring consultants to help manage the "over praised" Me Generation. The result? Kudos for showing up to work on time! Awards for getting a report in! Forget Employee of the Month — how about Employee of the Day! Some managers are resistant, saying the only praise they ever got was a paycheck.

Who is responsible for producing this generation of emotionally needy young adults? The Baby Boomers have only themselves to blame.

Stories like that one have been popping up all over the place lately. As someone who is smack-dab in the middle of that generation, I just have to say, "I don't buy it."

For starters, none of that crap ever happened to me, at least that I can remember. I know for damn sure that in high school no one got undeserved praise, there were no "gold stars" for anything but excellence, and no one was shouting from the rafters, "You're so special!" It didn't happen. And I was in the apparently decrepit and useless public school system.

And no one I know is like that either. Perhaps I don't associate with the right people to see it, but no one I know is like this. I know a decent number of people in this age group fairly well (a given person's range of acquaintances is roughly 100-200 people), and I don't know of a single person who has had to be coddled in order to survive. You know what? Those people don't survive. Someone who needs praise in order to get motivated will fail out of Stanford (or any real college) in a few terms, and usually a couple of F's is all it takes to get someone's ass in gear (I've seen it happen). If not, maybe they'll wake up when they're kicked out on their ass.

I want to know how these same damn analysts can say that this generation is overcompetative, and at the same time weak. One day you'll hear how the boomers' ridiculously high expectations are crushing their children, the next how their coddling has ruined them. Well which is it? You can't have it both ways!

Personally, as someone who actually is in this generation group, they're both crap. There's pressure on us, but there's always been pressure on kids. And the people I know are all hard-working, motivated, talented people, just like everyone else. Sometimes they break down, just like everyone else. Maybe my generation really is different from the previous ones, but I'm not seeing it, and if it really is as bad as everyone says, I think that I would.

Personally, I think that if these kids need special management that's not worth the time or effort, then their employers should fire them. Is it really that hard to say, "You're too much of a freakin' baby, so we're letting you go. Grow up and maybe you'll be able to get a job." I can't think of any way for them to grow up faster.



  • Every generation has its version of "These kids today." It's always been bullshit. Just a product of an aging population who forgets what buffoons they were when they were young.

    The people who are talking about this were probably driving around in buses looking like animals when they were the age of the current twentysomething workforce.

    By Blogger BlackSun, at 11:56 AM, May 30, 2007  

  • Yeah, ever generation has it's "those kids today" but with each generation it seems to push envelope more. Yesterday, it was the beatles. Today it's marilyn manson, beastility, and who knows what else. I'm all for letting adults be adults, but with the internet being so open and pervasive, it makes the kids especially vulnerable, although I'm not for internet censorship. However, I don't see a solution since most parents are at work all the time.

    By Anonymous mark, at 12:16 PM, May 30, 2007  

  • mark, what a hoot. You're falling into exactly the same fallacy. "These kids today...Marilyn Manson...beastility (sic)" It's bestiality, if you wondered.

    Irony meter--pegged!

    By Blogger BlackSun, at 2:21 PM, May 30, 2007  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home